Future Sight? College Study Debunks Precognition
On this page
Does growing up make you less likely to believe in psychic powers?
Imagine you're 20 years old, standing at the crossroads between adolescence and adulthood, trying to figure out who you really are. Psychologist Jerome Tobacyk wondered: Does having a solid sense of identity make you more skeptical of paranormal claims? He tested 98 college students from the Bible Belt, measuring both their belief in psychic phenomena and how well they'd figured out their personal identity. What he found challenged his expectations entirely.
College students' psychological maturity had no relationship to their paranormal beliefs.
In 1985, a psychologist wondered whether young adults who had developed a stronger sense of personal identity would be more skeptical of paranormal claims. The study took place in America's Bible Belt, where traditional religious values might conflict with beliefs in psychic phenomena. This regional focus means the findings might not apply equally to students from more secular areas.
Having a strong sense of personal identity showed no relationship to skepticism about paranormal phenomena among college students.
Key Findings
- The hypothesis was completely wrong - there was no relationship between identity development and paranormal beliefs.
- Students who had a strong, well-developed sense of personal identity were just as likely to believe in psychic phenomena as those who were still figuring themselves out.
- The correlations were so weak they could easily be due to random chance.
What Is This About?
Researchers gave 98 college students two questionnaires to fill out. One measured how well-developed their sense of personal identity was - essentially, how clear they were about their values, goals, and who they wanted to be. The other questionnaire asked about their beliefs in various paranormal phenomena like psychic abilities, witchcraft, superstitions, and communication with spirits. The researchers then looked for statistical relationships between identity development and paranormal beliefs.
98 college students completed questionnaires measuring their level of identity achievement and beliefs in various paranormal phenomena including psi, witchcraft, and spiritualism.
No significant correlations were found between identity achievement and paranormal beliefs, contradicting the hypothesis that more mature identity development would lead to less paranormal belief.
How Good Is the Evidence?
The correlations ranged from -.15 to +.12 - essentially zero. For comparison, meaningful psychological relationships typically show correlations of .30 or higher, and strong relationships show .50 or above.
Supporters of this research might argue it shows paranormal beliefs are more complex than simple developmental psychology suggests, and that mature individuals can rationally hold such beliefs. Skeptics might point out that the study only looked at one aspect of psychological development, and that other factors like scientific literacy or critical thinking skills might be more relevant to paranormal belief formation.
Mainstream: Identity development and paranormal beliefs operate independently, suggesting belief formation involves different psychological processes. Moderate: The relationship between psychological maturity and paranormal beliefs may be more nuanced than originally theorized, requiring investigation of other developmental factors. Frontier: This supports the view that paranormal beliefs can be held by psychologically mature individuals and shouldn't be dismissed as developmental immaturity.
Many assume that psychological maturity automatically leads to skepticism about paranormal claims. This study suggests that belief in psychic phenomena may be independent of how well-developed someone's sense of identity is.
To settle whether psychological development affects paranormal beliefs, we'd need larger studies across different cultures, longitudinal tracking of the same people over time, and measurement of multiple aspects of psychological maturity. This study provides one data point by showing no relationship between identity achievement and paranormal beliefs in Bible Belt college students.
No support was found for this hypothesis since these nonsignificant Pearson correlations were obtained between Identity Achievement Scale scores and Paranormal Belief Subscale scores
Stance: Skeptical
What Does It Mean?
The most striking aspect is how this study flipped conventional wisdom on its head—showing that personal maturity and paranormal skepticism don't necessarily go hand in hand.
It's like assuming that people who are confident about their career goals would be less likely to believe in horoscopes - this study suggests that's not necessarily true.
If these results hold up, they suggest that paranormal beliefs might operate independently of general psychological development. This could mean that belief in psychic phenomena stems from different cognitive or cultural processes than previously thought. It might also indicate that dismissing such beliefs as simply 'immature' misses the real psychological mechanisms at work.
This study demonstrates that correlation research can disprove hypotheses just as effectively as it can support them - sometimes the most important finding is that two things are NOT related.
Understanding Terms
What This Study Claims
Findings
The hypothesis that identity achievement would be inversely related to paranormal beliefs was not supported
moderateNo significant correlations were found between identity achievement scores and any paranormal belief subscales
moderateMethodology
The study assumed that normative identity achievement in Bible Belt students would internalize values inconsistent with paranormal beliefs
inconclusiveInterpretations
Students with more stable identity development were not more likely to critically reject paranormal beliefs
moderateThis summary is for general information about current research. It does not constitute medical advice. The scientific interpretation of these results is debated among researchers. If personally affected, please consult qualified professionals.