Devil vs. Reincarnation: Faith's Paranormal Divide
On this page
Does your religion predict what paranormal things you believe?
Picture a college campus where students are filling out a survey about their beliefs in ghosts, ESP, and the Devil. What researchers discovered was unexpected: the most religious students were actually less likely to believe in paranormal phenomena like extrasensory perception, while those from different Christian denominations showed surprisingly different patterns of belief. The data revealed a complex web of faith, culture, and the supernatural that challenges our assumptions about who believes what.
Religious background strongly shapes which paranormal phenomena people find believable.
In 1992, researchers wanted to understand how religious beliefs influence what paranormal phenomena people accept. They surveyed 267 American college students about their religious backgrounds and beliefs in various supernatural phenomena. This study focused specifically on American university students, so the patterns might differ in other cultures or age groups.
The more important religion was to students, the less likely they were to believe in paranormal phenomena like ESP or astrology.
Key Findings
- Religious affiliation created distinct belief patterns: Protestants were more open to devil-related phenomena but rejected reincarnation and haunted houses.
- Catholics showed higher belief in astrology.
- Surprisingly, students who said religion was very important to them actually believed less in most paranormal phenomena, including some traditionally associated with their faith.
What Is This About?
The researchers created a survey asking students about their religious affiliation (Protestant, Catholic, other, or none) and how important religion was to them personally. They also asked about beliefs in various paranormal phenomena including the Devil, demonic possession, witches, astrology, extrasensory perception, reincarnation, and haunted houses. They then analyzed which religious groups were more or less likely to believe in each phenomenon.
Researchers surveyed 267 college students about their beliefs in various paranormal phenomena and analyzed how these beliefs correlated with religious affiliation and importance of religion.
Different religious groups showed distinct patterns of paranormal beliefs, with Protestants more likely to believe in devil-related phenomena but less in reincarnation, while students for whom religion was important showed generally lower paranormal beliefs.
How Good Is the Evidence?
267 college students participated — a medium-sized sample typical for belief surveys of this era, though smaller than modern large-scale studies that often include thousands of participants.
Supporters of this research argue it reveals important cultural patterns in how worldviews shape supernatural beliefs, helping explain why paranormal beliefs cluster in predictable ways. Skeptics point out that belief surveys don't tell us anything about whether these phenomena actually exist — they only map cultural attitudes. Both sides agree the findings reflect deeper questions about how religious and scientific worldviews interact in modern society.
Mainstream: This demonstrates how cultural and religious frameworks shape supernatural beliefs without implying the phenomena are real. Moderate: Religious worldviews may make people more or less receptive to different types of anomalous experiences. Frontier: Different religious traditions may preserve varying degrees of authentic spiritual knowledge about paranormal phenomena.
Common misconception: Religious people believe in more supernatural phenomena. Reality: This study found that highly religious students actually believed in fewer paranormal phenomena, suggesting organized religion may discourage non-doctrinal supernatural beliefs.
To settle questions about religion-paranormal belief relationships, we'd need large-scale cross-cultural studies, longitudinal tracking of belief changes, and investigation of underlying psychological mechanisms. This study provides a useful snapshot of American college students in 1992 but represents just one data point in mapping these complex cultural patterns.
A survey of beliefs about the paranormal was completed by 267 university students, examining relationships between religious affiliation and paranormal beliefs.
Stance: Mixed
What Does It Mean?
The most devoutly religious students were actually the biggest skeptics of ESP and astrology—completely flipping the stereotype of 'believers' versus 'skeptics.'
Think about how your family's religious background might influence whether you read horoscopes, believe in ghosts, or think psychic abilities are real — this study mapped those connections systematically.
If these patterns hold true more broadly, it could mean that the rise of secularization might actually correlate with increased openness to paranormal beliefs. This could reshape how we understand the human need for meaning and mystery—suggesting that when traditional religious frameworks weaken, people might turn to alternative supernatural explanations rather than purely materialistic worldviews.
Survey studies like this reveal cultural patterns but can't establish causation — we don't know if religion shapes paranormal beliefs, if certain personalities are drawn to both, or if other factors explain the correlations.
Understanding Terms
What This Study Claims
Findings
Students for whom religion was important showed lower belief in Devil, possession, astrology, extrasensory perception, and reincarnation
moderateCatholics were more likely to believe in astrology compared to other religious groups
moderateProtestants were less likely to believe in reincarnation or haunted houses compared to other groups
moderateProtestants were more likely to believe in the Devil, possession by the Devil, and witches compared to other religious groups
moderateThis summary is for general information about current research. It does not constitute medical advice. The scientific interpretation of these results is debated among researchers. If personally affected, please consult qualified professionals.