Luck or Levitation? Thoughts vs. Machines
On this page
What personality traits make someone more superstitious?
Picture this: You're watching a basketball player bounce the ball exactly three times before every free throw, or you notice your colleague always wears the same 'lucky' shirt to important meetings. What makes some people more superstitious than others? Researchers decided to map the personality landscape of superstition, surveying hundreds of people about their beliefs, habits, and worldviews. What they discovered was a fascinating web of connections that might surprise you.
Superstitious people tend to believe in psychokinesis and other paranormal phenomena.
Consumer psychology researchers wanted to understand what makes some people more superstitious than others, and how superstitious thinking affects everyday decisions. They conducted two studies examining personality traits and belief patterns in adults of different ages.
The data suggest that superstitious thinking isn't random—it appears to cluster with specific personality traits and beliefs in predictable patterns.
Key Findings
- Superstitious people were more likely to believe in psychokinesis, astrology, magic, and mythical creatures like the Loch Ness monster.
- Interestingly, older adults with less interest in learning new things showed higher superstition, as did people interested in sports and those who believe in fate.
What Is This About?
The researchers gave participants personality questionnaires and surveys about their beliefs in various supernatural and paranormal phenomena. They looked for patterns between personality traits (like need for learning, sports interest) and superstitious beliefs. They also examined what other beliefs tend to cluster together with superstition, from astrology to attitudes about genetic engineering.
Two exploratory studies using personality questionnaires to examine what traits predict superstitious beliefs and what other beliefs correlate with superstition.
Superstition was associated with lower learning motivation in older adults, sports interest, belief in fate, and correlated with beliefs in paranormal phenomena including psychokinesis.
How Good Is the Evidence?
The study found 113 citations over 20 years, indicating moderate academic interest in the psychology of superstitious thinking compared to core parapsychology research.
Supporters see this as valuable mapping of belief systems and personality correlates that could inform education and decision-making research. Skeptics argue that studying belief patterns doesn't validate the beliefs themselves and worry about reinforcing pseudoscientific thinking. Both sides generally agree that understanding the psychology of belief formation is scientifically legitimate.
Mainstream: This is standard personality psychology research examining belief correlations. Moderate: The findings suggest interesting cognitive patterns that might inform our understanding of anomalous experiences. Frontier: These belief clusters might reflect genuine intuitive sensitivity to phenomena science hasn't yet explained.
This study doesn't test whether psychokinesis actually exists - it only examines whether people who are generally superstitious also tend to believe in it.
To establish causation, we'd need longitudinal studies tracking belief changes over time, experimental manipulations of personality factors, and replication across cultures. This study meets the basic criteria for correlation research but cannot establish whether personality traits cause superstitious beliefs or vice versa.
The results suggested that the consequences of superstition might include beliefs in astrology, magic, psychokinesis, and the existence of fictitious creatures.
Stance: Mixed
What Does It Mean?
The most intriguing finding? People who believed in superstitions were also more likely to believe in psychokinesis—the idea that minds can directly influence physical objects—suggesting our brains might organize 'impossible' beliefs into coherent worldviews.
Think about athletes who wear lucky socks or people who avoid walking under ladders - this research explores whether such superstitious thinking connects to believing in mind-over-matter abilities.
If these patterns hold up in larger studies, they could reshape how we understand belief formation and decision-making. It might mean that certain personality combinations naturally gravitate toward non-conventional explanations for events, potentially influencing everything from voting patterns to health choices. This could also inform more personalized approaches to education and communication about scientific topics.
Correlation studies like this can reveal interesting patterns but cannot prove that one factor causes another - personality traits and beliefs might influence each other bidirectionally or both be caused by a third factor.
Understanding Terms
What This Study Claims
Findings
Sports interest and belief in fate are associated with increased superstitious thinking
moderateLower need for learning among older adults predicts higher superstitious beliefs
moderateSuperstitious beliefs correlate with belief in psychokinesis among other paranormal phenomena
moderateSuperstitious beliefs negatively correlate with acceptance of genetic engineering in food products
moderateSuperstitious people show decreased belief in heaven and hell compared to other religious concepts
moderateThis summary is for general information about current research. It does not constitute medical advice. The scientific interpretation of these results is debated among researchers. If personally affected, please consult qualified professionals.