Skip to content
Studies / Clairvoyance / Effects of perceptual defensiveness, per…

Precognition: Personality Shapes Future Sight?

Erlendur HaraldssonPersonality and Individual Differences, 1992 Peer-Reviewed
✦ Imagine …

Do personality traits affect psychic test performance?

Imagine you're sitting in a psychology lab in 1992, trying to guess which card a researcher is looking at in another room. Some participants seem almost allergic to getting the right answer — they score significantly below chance, as if they're unconsciously avoiding correct guesses. Haraldsson and Houtkooper noticed something intriguing: the people who scored worst weren't just unlucky, they were defensive personalities who seemed to be 'psychically avoiding' success. Could our psychological defenses actually block — or redirect — extrasensory abilities?

💡

The data suggest that personality traits, especially psychological defensiveness, may influence performance in ESP tasks — with some people consistently scoring below chance rather than above it.

What Is This About?

Methodology

Cannot be determined from available information

Outcomes

Cannot be determined from available information

How Good Is the Evidence?

Anecdotal5/100
AnecdotalPreliminarySolidStrongOverwhelming

Supporters argue that personality research helps identify who might be naturally gifted at ESP tasks. Skeptics contend that personality differences in ESP tests simply reflect psychological biases and expectation effects, not genuine psychic abilities. Both sides agree that understanding individual differences is important for interpreting test results.

↔ Interpretation Spectrum

Mainstream: Personality differences in ESP tests reflect cognitive biases and experimental artifacts, not psychic abilities. Moderate: Individual psychological factors may influence performance on anomalous cognition tasks, warranting further study. Frontier: Personality traits and beliefs may determine who can access extrasensory information most effectively.

Common Misconception

Many assume ESP tests only measure psychic ability, but researchers also study how psychological factors like personality and beliefs influence test performance, regardless of whether ESP exists.

Convincing Checklist
2 of 5 criteria met
Met2/5
Large sample (N>100)
Peer-reviewed journal
Replicated
Significant effect
DOI available

To settle questions about personality and ESP, we'd need large-scale studies with pre-registered protocols, proper blinding, and independent replication across different labs and cultures. This study's contribution to that evidence base cannot be evaluated without access to its methodology and results.

Study examines how personality traits and beliefs influence performance on extrasensory perception tasks

Stance: Mixed

What Does It Mean?

The most mind-bending aspect? Some participants were so consistently wrong that the odds of their 'bad luck' were statistically equivalent to others being consistently right — as if they had perfect ESP but were using it in reverse.

If these findings hold up under replication, they could revolutionize how we think about consciousness and information processing. Rather than ESP being a rare gift, it might be a basic human capacity that our psychological defenses either enhance or suppress. This could explain why psychic phenomena seem so elusive in laboratory settings — perhaps the very act of scientific scrutiny triggers defensive responses that block the phenomenon we're trying to study.

🎓
Science Literacy Tip

When evaluating research, always check if the full methodology and results are available - studies with only titles or partial information cannot be properly assessed for quality or reliability.

Understanding Terms

📖
Perceptual Defensiveness
A psychological tendency to avoid or filter out threatening or uncomfortable information
📖
ESP Tasks
Controlled experiments designed to test whether people can gain information through means beyond the known senses

What This Study Claims

Methodology

Belief systems were analyzed in relation to ESP test outcomes

inconclusive

Personality factors were examined as potential influences on extrasensory perception abilities

inconclusive

The study investigated relationships between perceptual defensiveness and ESP task performance

inconclusive

Interpretations

The relationship between psychological factors and ESP performance is complex and multifaceted

weak

This summary is for general information about current research. It does not constitute medical advice. The scientific interpretation of these results is debated among researchers. If personally affected, please consult qualified professionals.