Twin Telepathy: Fact or Fiction in '73?
On this page
Do identical twins share a psychic connection?
Imagine you're an identical twin, and you suddenly get the urge to call your sibling — only to find out they were just thinking about you too. In 1973, researchers Gary France and Robert Hogan decided to test whether this kind of mental connection might be more than coincidence. They gave twins and siblings ESP card tests to see if genetic similarity might influence extrasensory abilities. What they found adds another piece to the puzzle of whether psychic abilities could run in families.
Researchers found hints that ESP abilities might run in families, especially identical twins.
In 1973, researchers investigated whether the special bond many identical twins report might extend to genuine psychic abilities. They built on earlier studies that had explored whether extrasensory perception could be inherited like other traits. The question was whether twins, who share either identical or similar genes, might also share unusual mental abilities.
This study explored whether genetic similarity between twins and siblings might influence extrasensory perception abilities, building on earlier hints that identical twins show more similar ESP patterns than fraternal twins.
Key Findings
- The results were mixed - no group showed clear ESP abilities above chance levels.
- However, identical twins performed more similarly to each other than fraternal twins did, suggesting that whatever influences ESP test performance might have a genetic component.
- The researchers acknowledged this was far from conclusive evidence.
What Is This About?
The researchers gave twins and siblings the classic Zener ESP card test - where one person tries to guess which of five symbols (circle, cross, wavy lines, square, or star) another person is looking at. They compared how similar the performance was between identical twins (who share 100% of their genes) versus fraternal twins (who share about 50% like regular siblings). They also looked at personality traits that might influence ESP test performance.
Researchers tested twins and siblings using Zener ESP cards to measure thought concordance and analyzed personality variables associated with extrasensory perception scoring behavior.
The study examined two aspects of scoring behavior on ESP tests, focusing on the relationship between twin type (identical vs fraternal) and ESP performance patterns.
How Good Is the Evidence?
While specific numbers aren't provided in the abstract, the study found patterns of similarity between identical twins that exceeded what was seen in fraternal twins - a difference that, while not statistically significant for ESP itself, mirrors patterns seen in studies of inherited psychological traits.
Supporters argue that the greater similarity between identical twins hints at a genetic component to psychic abilities, even if the abilities themselves weren't clearly demonstrated. Skeptics point out that no group actually showed ESP above chance levels, and that genetic similarities in test-taking style or personality could explain the twin patterns without invoking psychic phenomena. Both sides agree more rigorous research is needed.
Mainstream: The study found no evidence for ESP and the twin similarities likely reflect shared genetics affecting test-taking behavior or personality. Moderate: While ESP wasn't demonstrated, the genetic patterns are intriguing and warrant further investigation with better controls. Frontier: The identical twin similarities suggest ESP abilities may have a hereditary component that future research could uncover.
Many people think this study proved twins have psychic powers. Actually, it found no significant ESP abilities in any group - the interesting finding was just that identical twins showed more similar patterns of performance than fraternal twins, which could suggest genetic influences on whatever psychological factors affect ESP test results.
To settle whether ESP has a genetic component would require large-scale twin studies with proper controls, pre-registered protocols, and independent replication. The study would need thousands of twin pairs, rigorous blinding, and meta-analysis across multiple labs. This 1973 study provides only preliminary observations without the statistical power or controls needed for definitive conclusions.
Currently, no study has reported significant results in favor of any group for ESP. However, Nash and Buzby noted a greater similarity between identical twin pairs than fraternal twin pairs, which they interpreted as consistent with the idea that variations in ESP have a genetic basis.
Stance: Mixed
What Does It Mean?
The idea that psychic abilities might literally run in families — encoded in our DNA alongside eye color and height — challenges everything we think we know about the boundaries of human consciousness.
Think about how identical twins often finish each other's sentences or call each other at the same time. This study tested whether such seemingly psychic moments might reflect actual extrasensory abilities that run in families, like how musical talent or intelligence can be inherited.
If these findings were to show robust genetic influences on ESP abilities, it could revolutionize our understanding of consciousness and suggest that psychic phenomena operate through biological mechanisms we don't yet understand. This might also mean that certain families or genetic lineages could have enhanced intuitive abilities. Such discoveries could bridge the gap between materialist neuroscience and reports of unexplained mental phenomena.
Twin studies are a powerful tool for separating nature from nurture - by comparing identical twins (who share 100% of genes) with fraternal twins (who share ~50%), researchers can estimate how much genetics versus environment contributes to any trait.
Understanding Terms
What This Study Claims
Findings
Identical twin pairs showed greater similarity than fraternal twin pairs in ESP performance
weakNo study has reported significant results in favor of any group for ESP abilities in twins
moderateInterpretations
The greater similarity between identical twins is consistent with a genetic basis for ESP variations
weakLimitations
The relationship between personality and extrasensory perception remains unanswered
inconclusiveThis summary is for general information about current research. It does not constitute medical advice. The scientific interpretation of these results is debated among researchers. If personally affected, please consult qualified professionals.