Mind Over Matter? Hypnosis Boosts Psychic Belief
On this page
Are people who believe in psychic powers more hypnotizable?
Imagine sitting in a psychology lab, your eyes growing heavy as a researcher's voice guides you into a hypnotic trance. Now picture the same person later filling out a questionnaire about ghosts, telepathy, and supernatural experiences. In 1987, researchers Wagner and Ratzeburg wondered: Are these two scenarios connected? They tested 208 college students and discovered something intriguing about the relationship between how easily someone can be hypnotized and what they believe about the paranormal. The data revealed patterns that challenge our assumptions about belief, consciousness, and suggestibility.
College students who were easily hypnotized also reported more psychic experiences.
In 1987, researchers wanted to understand why some people believe in psychic phenomena while others don't. They focused on college students, testing whether the same mental traits that make someone susceptible to hypnosis might also make them more likely to believe in or experience paranormal events. Since this studied only American college students, the findings might not apply to other age groups or cultures.
People who are more easily hypnotized show statistically significant correlations with paranormal beliefs and reported psychic experiences.
Key Findings
- Students who scored higher on hypnotic susceptibility were significantly more likely to report having had psychic experiences and to hold positive attitudes toward parapsychology.
- They also attended church more often and scored higher on measures of anxiety, stereotypical thinking, and superstition.
What Is This About?
The researchers gave 208 college students the Harvard Scale of Hypnotic Susceptibility, which measures how easily someone can be hypnotized through tests like imagining their arm is getting heavy or that they can't open their eyes. They also had students fill out questionnaires about their paranormal beliefs, whether they'd had psychic experiences, how often they attended church, and various personality measures including anxiety levels and tendencies toward stereotypical thinking.
Researchers surveyed 208 college students, measuring their hypnotic susceptibility using the Harvard Scale and comparing it to their paranormal beliefs and personality traits.
Students who were more hypnotically susceptible also reported more psychic experiences and held stronger beliefs in paranormal phenomena.
How Good Is the Evidence?
208 college students participated — a medium-sized sample for psychology research of that era. The study found significant correlations, meaning the relationships were unlikely due to chance, though the exact strength of these relationships wasn't reported.
Supporters argue this shows that people with enhanced mental flexibility and openness are naturally more receptive to genuine psychic phenomena that others might miss. Skeptics contend it demonstrates that the same psychological traits that make someone susceptible to hypnotic suggestion also make them prone to false psychic experiences and magical thinking. Both sides agree the correlation exists, but disagree about what it means.
Mainstream: The correlation reflects shared psychological traits like suggestibility and fantasy-proneness that lead to false psychic experiences. Moderate: Hypnotically susceptible people may be more sensitive to subtle environmental cues that could include genuine anomalous phenomena. Frontier: Enhanced hypnotic susceptibility indicates greater psychic sensitivity and openness to non-ordinary states of consciousness.
This study doesn't prove that psychic experiences aren't real — it only shows that people who are easily hypnotized are more likely to report them. The correlation could mean hypnotizable people are more sensitive to real phenomena, or that they're more prone to misinterpreting normal events as psychic.
To settle this question, we'd need experimental studies that manipulate hypnotic susceptibility and measure changes in psychic experiences, plus longitudinal studies tracking people over time. We'd also need replication across different cultures and age groups. This study meets the basic criteria of using validated measures and finding significant correlations, but can't establish whether hypnotizability causes psychic beliefs or vice versa.
The Harvard scale scores correlated significantly with reported psychic experiences, church attendance, Taylor's Anxiety Scale, Adorno's Stereotypy/Superstition, and attitudes toward parapsychology and the supernatural.
Stance: Supportive
What Does It Mean?
The study found that the same psychological trait that makes someone slip easily into a hypnotic trance also correlates with believing in telepathy and reporting psychic experiences. It's as if there's an invisible thread connecting our capacity for altered consciousness with our openness to the extraordinary.
Think about how some people are more suggestible in general — they're the ones who get absorbed in movies, follow guided meditations easily, or are influenced by peer pressure. This study suggests these same people might also be more open to believing they've had psychic experiences.
If these correlations prove robust, they might suggest that certain states of consciousness make people more receptive to experiences that others would dismiss. This could mean that paranormal believers aren't necessarily more gullible, but rather have different cognitive processing styles that allow for more fluid boundaries between imagination and reality. It raises profound questions about the nature of consciousness itself and whether some people are simply wired to perceive reality differently.
Correlation studies like this one can reveal interesting patterns but can't tell us about cause and effect — the relationship between hypnotizability and psychic beliefs could run in either direction or both could be caused by a third factor.
Understanding Terms
What This Study Claims
Findings
Students with higher hypnotic susceptibility showed stronger attitudes toward parapsychology and supernatural phenomena
moderateHypnotic susceptibility significantly correlated with reported psychic experiences among college students
moderateHypnotic susceptibility correlated with church attendance and measures of stereotypy and superstition
moderateInterpretations
The correlations suggest a core of attitudes that may cause concern for critics of the paranormal
weakThis summary is for general information about current research. It does not constitute medical advice. The scientific interpretation of these results is debated among researchers. If personally affected, please consult qualified professionals.