Teen Minds: Less Telepathy, More Science?
On this page
Does science education make you less likely to believe in psychic powers?
Picture a high school hallway where students debate whether psychic abilities are real, ghosts exist, or horoscopes actually work. In 1984, researchers decided to systematically measure what 193 eleventh-graders actually believed about the paranormal — and then compare their answers to college students. What they discovered challenges common assumptions about who believes in mysterious phenomena and why. The results paint an unexpected picture of how education and age shape our openness to the unexplained.
High school students with more science courses showed less belief in paranormal phenomena.
In 1984, researchers wanted to understand how education affects belief in the paranormal. They surveyed 193 eleventh-grade students using a comprehensive questionnaire that measured beliefs in everything from ESP to witchcraft. The study was conducted during a time when paranormal beliefs were becoming increasingly popular in mainstream culture.
High school students showed significantly less belief in paranormal phenomena than college students, with more science courses correlating with even greater skepticism.
Key Findings
- High school students were significantly more skeptical about paranormal phenomena than college students, particularly regarding psi abilities, extraordinary life forms, and witchcraft.
- Students who took more science courses showed lower belief in paranormal phenomena overall.
- Interestingly, students with higher grades were more likely to hold traditional religious beliefs, and those in advanced academic programs were less superstitious.
What Is This About?
The researchers gave students a detailed questionnaire called the Paranormal Belief Scale, which measures belief in seven different categories: traditional religious belief, psi phenomena (like telepathy), witchcraft, spiritualism, superstition, extraordinary life forms, and precognition. They then looked at how these beliefs related to the students' academic performance, number of science courses taken, and academic track level. Finally, they compared the high school students' responses to those of college students from a previous study.
Researchers gave 193 high school students a questionnaire measuring beliefs in seven types of paranormal phenomena and compared their responses to college students.
High school students showed significantly less belief in paranormal phenomena overall, with science education correlating with lower belief levels.
How Good Is the Evidence?
The study found a significant inverse correlation between science courses and paranormal belief - meaning for every additional science course, belief scores decreased measurably. This pattern was strongest for psi beliefs and traditional religious beliefs, suggesting science education has a specific impact on supernatural thinking.
Supporters of paranormal phenomena argue this study simply shows educational bias against non-mainstream ideas, and that academic skepticism doesn't disprove genuine psychic abilities. Skeptics point to this as evidence that critical thinking and scientific literacy naturally lead people away from unsupported beliefs. Both sides agree that education shapes belief patterns, but disagree about whether this represents progress toward truth or away from open-mindedness.
Mainstream: Science education promotes critical thinking that naturally reduces belief in unsubstantiated claims. Moderate: Educational background influences belief patterns, but this doesn't necessarily determine truth about paranormal phenomena. Frontier: Academic institutions may inadvertently suppress consideration of genuine anomalous phenomena through cultural bias.
This study doesn't prove that paranormal phenomena don't exist - it only shows that science education correlates with lower belief levels. The relationship could work in multiple directions: science education might reduce belief, or naturally skeptical people might gravitate toward science courses.
To settle questions about education's effect on paranormal beliefs, we'd need longitudinal studies tracking the same students over time, larger sample sizes, and studies across different cultures and educational systems. This study meets the criteria of using established measures and finding statistically significant correlations, but it's limited by its cross-sectional design and single cultural context.
Generally, high school students were greater disbelievers in paranormal phenomena than college students.
Stance: Skeptical
What Does It Mean?
The most surprising finding? College students were actually MORE likely to believe in psychic phenomena, witchcraft, and extraordinary life forms than high schoolers — completely opposite to what most people would expect about education and skepticism.
Think about how your beliefs about luck, intuition, or 'gut feelings' might change as you learn more about statistics and scientific thinking. This study suggests that exposure to scientific reasoning gradually shifts how people evaluate extraordinary claims.
If these patterns hold true across cultures and time periods, it could suggest that there's a specific developmental window where openness to extraordinary claims peaks before settling into more stable belief patterns. This might inform how we approach science education and critical thinking instruction. It also raises intriguing questions about whether intellectual maturity necessarily leads to dismissal of unconventional possibilities.
This study demonstrates that correlation doesn't equal causation - while science education and lower paranormal belief go together, we can't tell if science courses reduce belief, or if naturally skeptical students simply choose more science classes.
Understanding Terms
What This Study Claims
Findings
High school students showed significantly less belief in paranormal phenomena than college students on total scores and three specific subscales
moderateStudents in accelerated academic tracks showed significantly less belief in superstition than other students
moderateNumber of science courses taken correlated significantly and inversely with paranormal belief scores
moderateTraditional religious belief scores were significantly and directly associated with grade point average
moderateThis summary is for general information about current research. It does not constitute medical advice. The scientific interpretation of these results is debated among researchers. If personally affected, please consult qualified professionals.