Men See UFOs: Gender & the Paranormal
On this page
Do men and women believe differently in the paranormal?
Picture a psychology classroom in 1998: 125 college students fill out a survey about their beliefs in ESP, ghosts, and UFOs before their first psychology class. Months later, after learning about scientific thinking and research methods, they take the same survey again. The researchers expected education might change their paranormal beliefs — but something unexpected emerged from the data. Instead of education making the difference, it was gender that created the most striking patterns.
College men showed stronger paranormal beliefs than women across multiple categories.
In 1998, researchers wanted to understand how gender might influence paranormal beliefs among college students. They also wondered whether taking a psychology course might change these beliefs. This study focused on American undergraduate students, so the findings might not apply equally to other cultures or age groups.
Male college students showed significantly stronger beliefs in paranormal phenomena like ESP, life after death, and UFO visits than their female counterparts — and a psychology education didn't change either group's beliefs.
Key Findings
- Men consistently scored higher than women on paranormal beliefs, especially regarding life after death, ESP, and UFOs.
- Surprisingly, taking a psychology course didn't change anyone's beliefs significantly.
- The most popular beliefs overall were life after death and ESP, while physical contact with ghosts was least believed.
What Is This About?
The researchers gave 125 college students a 12-question survey about paranormal beliefs at the beginning of their psychology course. The survey asked about things like life after death, ESP, personal psychic experiences, and UFOs. Students rated their agreement on a scale from 1 to 5. At the end of the semester, the same students took the survey again to see if their beliefs had changed after learning about psychology.
125 college students completed a 12-item survey about paranormal beliefs before and after taking a general psychology course.
Men showed significantly stronger paranormal beliefs than women across multiple categories, with no significant changes after the psychology course.
How Good Is the Evidence?
125 students participated - a medium-sized sample for this type of survey research. The gender differences were statistically significant, meaning they're unlikely due to chance. Similar studies typically find 40-60% of college students hold some paranormal beliefs.
Supporters of paranormal research might point to these consistent gender differences as evidence that something real underlies these beliefs. Skeptics would argue this study only shows cultural and psychological differences in belief formation, not evidence for paranormal phenomena themselves. Both sides agree that beliefs don't equal reality - what people think happened isn't the same as what actually happened.
Mainstream: These gender differences reflect cultural socialization and psychological factors, with no implications for paranormal reality. Moderate: The patterns might reveal genuine differences in how men and women process unusual experiences, worth further study. Frontier: Consistent belief patterns across genders could indicate underlying sensitivity differences to genuine paranormal phenomena.
Many people assume women are more likely to believe in paranormal phenomena, but this study found the opposite. However, this doesn't mean the paranormal claims are true or false - it only tells us about belief patterns, not reality.
To settle questions about gender differences in paranormal beliefs, we'd need large-scale studies across multiple cultures, longitudinal tracking of belief changes over time, and investigation of the underlying psychological mechanisms. This study provides a useful data point but represents just one snapshot of American college students in the 1990s.
Men scored significantly higher than women on scale values for beliefs regarding life after death, the existence of extrasensory perception, having at least one extrasensory experience, and UFOs with people from other places visiting our planet.
Stance: Mixed
What Does It Mean?
The most striking finding? A full semester of scientific psychology training — learning about research methods, statistical thinking, and evidence evaluation — had zero measurable impact on students' paranormal beliefs.
Think about how men and women in your life talk about ghost stories, horoscopes, or 'sixth sense' moments. This study suggests men might be more likely to say they believe in or have experienced such things, contrary to common stereotypes about women being more 'mystical.'
If these gender patterns hold across larger populations, it could reshape how we understand the psychology of belief and the social factors that influence our openness to unconventional ideas. The resistance of these beliefs to formal education might suggest they serve deeper psychological or social functions than previously thought.
This study shows that beliefs can be surprisingly stable - even education designed to teach critical thinking didn't change students' paranormal beliefs, suggesting that deeply held convictions resist simple exposure to contradictory information.
Understanding Terms
What This Study Claims
Findings
Men scored significantly higher than women on beliefs in life after death, ESP existence, personal ESP experiences, and UFO visitation
moderateBeliefs in physical ghost contact, auras, and psychokinesis ranked lowest in endorsement
moderateBelief in life after death, precognitive dreams, and ESP existence ranked highest in overall endorsement
moderateTaking a general psychology course did not significantly change paranormal beliefs
moderateThis summary is for general information about current research. It does not constitute medical advice. The scientific interpretation of these results is debated among researchers. If personally affected, please consult qualified professionals.